I’ve had an Amazon Echo (Alexa) in my house for quite a while. One of “Alexa’s” biggest disappointments is her lack of knowledge. Often, after hearing Alexa say “I’m sorry, I don’t understand the question you asked.”, I found myself turning to Google on my phone for the answer.
The Google Home is an Echo-like assistant for your home that has the knowledge base of Google behind it. I can also control my IoT devices like WeMo, SmartThings and Philips like my Echo does. After using it since November, I feel I have a decent understanding of the advantages and disadvantages of using it vs. the Amazon Echo.
- Smarter – It has the power of Google Search behind it so it can answer far more questions than the Amazon Echo. Google Assistant can be a useful tool.
- Better Looking – Sure, it does look like an air freshener but it’s better looking than the original Amazon Echo. You can also change the color of the Google Home if you are into that type of thing.
- Music – It works seamlessly with Google Music, which I like better than Amazon’s alternative. Services like Spotify and Pandora work on either unit.
- Sound – Music sounds a lot better coming from the Google Home speaker than the original Amazon Echo. *I also have an Echo dot. Using the Echo dot with an external speaker is a nice feature.
- Chromecast Support – We have 6 Chromecasts in our house. I love that I can say:
- Play 80’s rock music in the Living Room
- Play Justin Timberlake music upstairs
- Play Studio C videos on the Family Room TV
- It’s younger than Amazon Echo. Since the Echo has been around longer there are far more devices and partners that work with it. They both are adding new features all the time but since the Echo had a head start, it had the advantage.
- Ordering product. There’s something really nice about saying “Alexa, order more AA batteries” when you are running low that makes the Echo very nice. Amazon has a great advantage here.
Overall, I really like the Google Home. Unless you want the ability to order directly from Amazon with your internet connected assistant, I would suggest the Google Home over the Alexa. For now, both devices have a place in my home.
The Amazon Echo was quite a surprise when it was released in late 2014. A smart speaker/virtual assistant that works with your voice. Even though it’s a pretty cool device, it took a while to gain popularity. This was partly because it wasn’t available to the general public for the first 6-months or so.
I’ve grown to really love it. The array of mics around the top of the Echo allows the device to know where you are. If the Echo is in the middle of the room and there are people talking all around it, it knows where you are and listens to only you even if there are other people talking in the room.
You activate it by saying a keyword. By default it is called Alexa but you can also use Amazon or Echo if you prefer those. After saying the keyword the light on top of the device points in your direction showing you where it is listening. You then give it a command.
You can ask Alexa to play music for you from your Amazon music account as well as Spotify, iHeartRadio, or Pandora accounts. I listen to KFI radio by saying “Alexa, play KFI”
You can ask Alexa to order Amazon products for you. It’s really easy if you’ve ordered the item before. When I run out of bacon crumbles, I simply say “Alexa, order more bacon crumbles”. She will order your usual product and it arrives 2 days later. It’s as simple as that. You can put a code on the echo if you don’t want your kids ordering things that you don’t know about until it arrives.
Just like Siri or Google Assistant, you can ask general questions of Alexa. She’s not quite as smart as Siri or Google but she’s not that bad either. You can ask:
- Alexa, when was Alyssa Milano born?
- Alexa, who is Grace Vanderwaal?
- Alexa, tell me a Star Wars Joke?
- Alexa, what is the weather going to be like today?
- Alexa, how long will it take me to get to work today?
- Alexa, how many tablespoons in a cup?
- Alexa, order me an Uber.
- Alexa, set timer for 3 minutes.
- Alexa, what is the latest news?
My favorite use of the Amazon Echo has got to be Home Automation. I’ve hooked it smart devices in my house like my WeMo Lights and Rachio sprinklers. Doing this allows an Echo owner to ask things like:
- Alexa, turn on the family room light
- Alexa, Ask Rachio to water Zone 3 for 15 minutes
- Alexa, turn off the lights downstairs
- Alexa, Lock the font door
- Alexa, how much gas is in my Ford?
- Alexa, turn up the thermostat to 78 degrees.
Amazon Echo Devices
There are 3 different types of Amazon devices.
The Original Echo has a good speaker in it but it’s not a great speaker. If you want great sound to play music out of you can use the Echo Dot to hook into a better speaker. The echo Dot is basically Alexa without the speaker. It’s made to connect to a better speaker system. You can talk to the Echo Dot and it replies out of your speaker system.
For those who don’t want the convenience of being able to talk to Echo at anytime, there is the Amazon Tap. You press a button (tap) first and then ask Alexa to help you.
I love my Amazon Echo. It’s a great device. I recommend it to anyone who has ever wanted to talk to your house. It’s been such a hit that there will be a lot of copy cats. Look for similar devices soon from the likes of Google, Apple, Samsung and Microsoft. I personally am excited for the Google Home device that will probably do a lot of the same things but will be more integrated into Google Services. We’ll know more about it after Google’s Early October event.